QUICK CLICKS:

Higher Ed Home


Table of Contents
Jan.'99

Advocate Online

They're talking on campus...

On the Road

Action Line

In the Know

From Capital to Campus

NEA Affiliates in Action

Thriving in Academe

Higher Education News

Money Savvy

The Dialogue

Speak out

Current Issue

Archived Issues

News on our site. Join our interactive community and mailing lists Surf our annotated links Technology in higher education Unions Tenure Envision the future of higher education

Best Practices: Some Guideline's for Meaningful Evaluation

Some tips for making student ratings work:

  • Before beginning, know the purpose of the evaluation and who will use the ratings.
  • Include all stakeholders in decisions about evaluation process and policy.
  • Keep in mind a balance between individual and institutional needs.
  • Publicly present clear information about the evaluation criteria, process, and procedures.
  • Establish legally defensible process and a system for grievances.
  • Include resources for the improvement and support of teaching and teachers.
  • Build a real "system" for evaluation, not a haphazard and unsystematic process.
  • Establish clear lines of responsibility and reporting for system administrators.
  • Invest in the evaluation system and evaluate it regularly.
  • Use, adapt, or develop instrumentation suited to institutional and individual needs.
  • Use multiple sources of information from several situations.
  • Keep ratings data and validate the instruments used.
  • Produce reports that can be easily and accurately understood.
  • Educate the users of rating results to avoid misuse and misinterpretation.
  • Keep formative evaluation confidential and separate from summative decision making.
  • In summative decisions, compare teachers on the basis of data from similar situations.
  • Consider the appropriate use of evaluation data for assessment and other purposes.
  • Seek expert, outside assistance as needed.

Post your comments on our "Thriving in Academe" discussion board.

Back to Thriving in Academe


nea's address