In the Know
Intense Study Breeds Success
Answers in the Tool Box, a monograph from the U.S. Department of
Education, provides new and surprising information on pre-college factors that
contribute to long-term bachelor's degree completion.
The study analyzes high school and college transcript records, test scores,
and surveys of a national sample of students from the time the students were in
the 10th grade in 1980 until roughly age 30 in 1993.
The key finding: An academically intense high school curriculum plays a more
significant role than either test scores, class rank, or academic grade point
average in predicting who will eventually be awarded a bachelor's degree.
An intensive high school program includes: 3.75 units of English and math,
with the highest level trigonometry or above; at least two units of science,
two units of a foreign language, two units of history or civics, and more than
one advanced placement course.
The report's findings also have implications for higher education.
The positive impact of a high academic intensity curriculum is far more
pronounced than any other pre-college indicator for African American and Latino
students. Colleges that emphasize test scores, grade point averages, and class
rank are likely to end up with lower degree completion rates.
Policies that seek to limit or eliminate the amount of remedial work that
takes place in four-year colleges are misguided, the report suggests, because
there are students whose deficiencies in preparation are minor and can be
remediated quickly without significantly lowering degree completion rates.
Notes the report: "There is no reason why all students cannot reach the
highest levels of the curriculum scale" because curriculum is something
that educators control.
One difficulty: For many poor and working class students, the resources for
an intensive curriculum are not available.
The report's recommendation: Colleges should work with high schools that are
lacking in resources in the areas of dual enrollment, direct provision of
courses by college professors, and bridge programs that begin in 10th grade.
Copies of Answers in the Tool Box are available from the U.S
Department of Education by calling 1-877-433-7827.
|